What price for the V&A?

Posted On Wednesday, 04 May 2005 02:00 Published by
Rate this item
(0 votes)
A politically inspired valuation likely

A FEW years ago BBC’s programme ‘Holidays’ rated places to be seen be-fore dying. Cape Town was voted the top city. Dying might be the common thread when prospective buyers eventually learn what Transnet wants for its 26% of the Victoria and Alfred Basin (V&A), Cape Town’s most popular tourist and shopping attraction, bringing in over 22 million visitors in 2004. If it will actually go on open sale?

"Whatever the value people must remember that the three Transnet Pension funds that hold the 74% balance have a right of first refusal on the sale." This according to Helgardt Mouton, spokesperson for Pradeep Marahaj, who is Transnet’s group executive: strategy and transformation. However the official valuation process has started, but he can’t comment on expected completion. Neither will he speculate on a price but agrees that most property experts in Cape Town, who have commented on the sale, have settled on in excess, some say well in excess, of R2 billion.

Staying on the dying theme, merely reaching a price might cause cardiac arrest, says Aletta Liebenberg, chairperson of the Cape Town Valuation Court. "It’s an almost impossible task, unless they divide it into separate entities and sell off parcels, but I don’t think even that is possible. It might be easier valuing Table Mountain."

Liebenberg would not even hazard a guess on the price, aside from ‘many billions’, even though she handled the R1 billion valuation of Cape Town Harbour "It will come down to what a buyer is prepared to pay. I believe it will be a politically inspired price. It has to be, because the V&A has become a national asset."

Liebenberg’s team is currently busy with individual valuations of V&A properties for rates purposes. "There are many unanswered questions, including who owns the buildings, what is the situation with registered leases, and who is ultimately responsible for rates and taxes. If I was advising potential buyers I’d suggest holding back until the rates queries are sorted out."

In 2004 the V&A’s combined turnover for the 338 915sq m mixed use site – hotels, retail, restaurants, offices, residential, and an entertainment of other uses – topped R2bn. If popularity and demand are an indication, then sample these asking prices: Retail rent – R350sq m, office rent R90sq m, other (parking, conference areas, etc) – on application, availability – zero. Residential availability - also zero, and prices are nudging R20m for a penthouse.

Regarding likely buyers for Public Enterprise Minister Alec Erwin’s sale of the century, if the pension funds don’t grab it that is, common consensus is that they will have to have a wall-to-wall black empowerment consortium, and it could involve overseas partners. The Congress of SA Trade Unions (Cosatu) has already hammered Erwin in advance for parting with the crown jewels, so expect its investment arm, Kopano Ke Matla, to be in on the action. At least its two million workers will have a trinket or two, if not the jewels.


Publisher: Cape Business News
Source: Cape Business News

Please publish modules in offcanvas position.